APTISI Transactions on Technopreneurship (ATT), published by Pandawan Sejahtera Indonesia, is committed to maintaining high standards of integrity, transparency, fairness, and accountability across all stages of the scholarly publishing process.

ATT establishes and enforces its publication ethics policies to govern the rights, roles, and responsibilities of authors, peer reviewers, editors, editorial board members, and the publisher. These policies apply from initial manuscript submission and editorial screening through double-blind peer review, publication, and post-publication management.

In shaping and updating its ethical guidelines, ATT aligns its practices with internationally recognized research integrity principles, including the COPE Core Practices. These external standards serve as primary reference benchmarks, while formal implementation and editorial decisions remain the direct responsibility of ATT’s editorial team and publisher.

Ethical Guideline for Journal Publication

ATT requires all participating actors in the publication workflow to uphold academic integrity and ethical conduct. Submitted manuscripts must represent original scholarly work, accurately detail methodology and findings, properly attribute prior literature, and conform to all institutional and international ethical standards.

Practices that undermine the reliability of the academic record including plagiarism, data fabrication or falsification, redundant/duplicate submission, improper authorship attribution, citation manipulation, and undisclosed conflicts of interest are strictly prohibited.

When potential ethical violations are identified, the editorial team conducts an objective review based on documented evidence. Authors, reviewers, or relevant parties may be asked to provide clarification, raw data, or background documentation. Editorial measures are taken proportionally according to the nature and severity of the issue.

Publisher and Editor Responsibilities

Pandawan Sejahtera Indonesia, as the publisher of ATT, upholds full editorial independence and provides the operational framework necessary for manuscript intake, peer review, digital publishing, and permanent access.

The Editor-in-Chief and the editorial board manage manuscript workflows in accordance with ATT’s established standards. Responsibilities include initial screening, reviewer assignment, assessment of review reports, author communications, and final publication decisions.

Editorial determinations are strictly based on academic quality, research originality, methodological rigor, clarity, and ethical compliance. Decisions are never influenced by financial considerations, Article Processing Charges (APCs), waiver status, institutional affiliations, or commercial sponsorship.

Publication Decisions and Fair Play

The Editor-in-Chief holds final authority for deciding which submitted manuscripts will be published in ATT, guided by peer-review evaluations and editorial assessments.

Manuscripts passing initial editorial screening undergo ATT’s double-blind peer-review process. Reviewer feedback provides essential advisory input, but ultimate editorial responsibility rests with the Editor-in-Chief or assigned handling editors.

ATT evaluates all submissions solely on intellectual merit and alignment with the journal's focus and scope. Authors receive fair and impartial evaluation regardless of race, gender, sexual orientation, religious belief, ethnic origin, citizenship, political philosophy, or institutional affiliation.

Confidentiality and Handling of Material

ATT maintains strict confidentiality regarding all submitted manuscripts, review reports, author communications, and editorial deliberation records.

Editors and reviewers must not disclose manuscript details, reviewer comments, or unpublished materials to unauthorized individuals. Information or insights gained through handling manuscripts must not be used for personal, academic, or commercial advantage.

Unless explicit consent is granted, reviewer identities remain fully anonymous under ATT's double-blind peer-review system. Confidential material is disclosed only when strictly necessary to investigate credible research misconduct or comply with legal requirements.

Disclosure and Conflicts of Interest

All authors, reviewers, and editors must transparently declare any financial, professional, personal, or institutional relationships that could bias their involvement in the publication process.

Authors must explicitly state funding sources and commercial affiliations related to the research. Reviewers must decline assignments if a potential conflict of interest prevents an objective and impartial evaluation.

Editors must recuse themselves from handling manuscripts where competing interests exist. In such events, the manuscript is reassigned to an independent member of the editorial board.

Complaints, Appeals, and Misconduct Handling

ATT welcomes inquiries and legitimate complaints concerning editorial workflows, peer-review practices, publication ethics, or published content. Complaints should be directed to the official editorial email address, accompanied by concrete supporting evidence and clear identification of the affected article or submission.

Receipt of a complaint is acknowledged within five (5) business days. Complaints are investigated impartially by the Editor-in-Chief or a designated editorial officer who has no personal conflict with the matter.

If a complaint directly involves the Editor-in-Chief, the matter is referred to the publisher (Pandawan Sejahtera Indonesia) or an independent ethics committee for impartial review. Complainants are formally notified of the final outcome once editorial assessments are completed.

Duties and Standards for Reviewers

Reviewers assist ATT editors in making informed publishing decisions and help authors refine their research.

  • Expertise and Availability: Reviewers should accept invitations only for manuscripts within their explicit technical competency and commit to completing evaluations within the agreed timeframe.

  • Objective Assessment: Reviews must be conducted objectively and constructively. Personal critiques directed at authors are unacceptable. All feedback must be supported by clear reasoning and scholarly evidence.

  • Confidentiality and AI Constraints: Reviewers must treat all review materials as confidential. To protect author intellectual property and confidentiality, reviewers must not input manuscript text or review materials into Generative AI tools or unauthorized automated applications.

  • Reporting Integrity Concerns: If a reviewer identifies potential plagiarism, duplicate publication, data anomalies, or citation manipulation, they must report their concerns confidentially to the handling editor without initiating independent inquiries.

  • Conflict Disclosures: Reviewers must decline evaluations if competing interests exist and must not demand citations to their own work simply to boost citation counts.

Duties and Responsibilities of Authors

Authors submitting to ATT bear primary responsibility for the validity, integrity, and originality of their published contributions.

  • Originality and Attribution: Submitted work must be original. Authors must correctly attribute all external ideas, text, figures, and data using precise citations and references.

  • Exclusive Submission: Simultaneous submission of the same work to more than one publication outlet is strictly forbidden. Substantially overlapping studies must be fully disclosed upon submission.

  • Data Integrity: Authors must present accurate research data without fabrication, falsification, or misleading manipulation. Primary data and documentation should be retained and provided to the journal if requested.

  • Authorship Criteria: Authorship must be limited to individuals who made significant contributions to the research design, execution, data analysis, or manuscript drafting. All co-authors must approve the submitted and final versions of the paper.

  • Human and Animal Rights: Studies involving human participants or animal models must demonstrate adherence to ethics committee approvals, informed consent protocols, and confidentiality protections.

  • Generative AI Use: Authors utilizing Generative AI tools in writing or research must comply with ATT’s Generative AI Policy. AI tools cannot be listed as authors. Authors remain fully accountable for all content, accuracy, citations, and ethical standards of their manuscript.

Data Fabrication and Falsification

ATT maintains a zero-tolerance policy for data fabrication, falsification, and image manipulation.

When potential data irregularities are detected during review or after publication, the editorial team will investigate and request raw research files or explanatory documentation from the authors.

If fabrication or falsification is confirmed prior to publication, the manuscript will be rejected immediately. If confirmed after publication, ATT will issue appropriate post-publication notices, up to and including formal article retraction.

Duplicate, Redundant, and Plagiarism Management

ATT scans all incoming manuscripts for textual similarity and potential overlap using specialized plagiarism detection software prior to peer review.

Manuscripts found to contain unoriginal content, unattributed text, or unauthorized redundant publishing will be rejected. If redundant or plagiarized material is identified post-publication, ATT will evaluate its impact on the scholarly record and issue corrections or retractions as warranted.

Post-Publication Updates, Corrections, and Retractions

ATT recognizes its duty to maintain the permanence and integrity of the scholarly record. Once published, articles remain part of the permanent record, but corrections or notices may be issued when necessary:

  • Corrections (Errata/Corrigenda): Issued if significant errors of fact, calculation, or layout are discovered that affect the interpretation or accuracy of the paper without invalidating its main conclusions.

  • Retractions: Executed in cases of severe ethical violations, widespread data fabrication, major plagiarism, or unresolvable methodological flaws that render the findings unscientific or invalid. Retraction notices are published transparently, clearly stating the reason for retraction and linking directly to the original article, which will remain accessible but clearly flagged as retracted.

  • Expressions of Concern: Issued by the Editor-in-Chief if an investigation into potential research misconduct is ongoing or inconclusive, but serious reliability concerns exist.

Digital Preservation and Archiving Policy

To ensure permanent access to published scientific work, Pandawan Sejahtera Indonesia secures long-term digital preservation for all ATT content.

All published articles are assigned persistent Digital Object Identifiers (DOIs) via Crossref. Complete electronic archives are preserved through digital archiving initiatives (including the PKP Preservation Network (PKP PN), LOCKSS, and CLOCKSS) to ensure continuous availability, readability, and open access to the academic community regardless of system changes or platform disruptions.